Fictional lab site. Every brand, product, price, offer and review here is invented; no purchase or contact happens.

BizPicks Lab

Best Payroll Software

Six payroll services compared on price, setup time and tax filing support.

We may earn a commission when you visit a provider through our links. How we make money.

1. Alderpay Payroll Best overall

Full-service payroll with automatic federal, state and local tax filing.

From $40 a month plus $6 per employee

  • Unlimited pay runs
  • Contractor payments in all 50 states
  • Time tracking is an add-on

Offer: First three months of payroll processing at no base fee (fictional). Offer code: BIZ-7K2Q. Get this offer It applies through the Get this offer link, or with the code typed on the Alderpay site. No membership or quote request is needed.

Visit Site Read review Pricing

2. Brightwick Payroll Best for retail

Payroll bundled with point-of-sale tip pooling.

From $35 a month plus $5 per employee

  • Tip distribution built in
  • Same-day deposit
  • Fewer HR features

Visit Site Read review Pricing

3. Quillstone Payroll Best for very small teams

A simple payroll service for teams under ten.

From $19 a month plus $4 per employee

  • Setup in a day
  • Low base fee
  • No multi-state support

4. Harrowgate HR Best for HR depth

Payroll inside a full HR suite with benefits administration.

From $80 a month plus $9 per employee

  • Benefits and onboarding
  • Compliance alerts
  • Higher cost

5. Tallowmere Pay Best for contractors

Contractor-first payments with year-end forms.

From $29 a month plus $6 per contractor

  • International contractors
  • Automatic 1099 forms
  • Limited W-2 support

6. Veldrin Payroll Best for accountants

Multi-client payroll for accounting firms.

Custom pricing

  • Client portal
  • Bulk pay runs
  • Quote required